Testing Edgy Vocals

These records are good for testing how edgy the vocals are.

Live Rust – Our Shootout Winner from 2012

From our 2012 shootout.

This KILLER live set, the ultimate Neil Young concert collection, combines brilliant early material, such as “After the Gold Rush,” with his wonderful middle-era material, including the amazing “My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue)” and “Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black)” and “Tonight’s the Night.”

Side One

A+++, As Good As It Gets (AGAIG)! This side has Neil solo, accompanying himself on guitar and harmonica. So full-bodied and natural, with just the right amount of ambience and space, this one is hard to beat.

Side Two

A++. Big, rich and open with present vocals.

Side Three

A++ to A+++. Full and rich with the solid, weighty low end required for this music to ROCK! The vocals are clear and present with no hardness or edge. Check out the harmonies on Cortez the Killer — not many copies let you hear each individual voice this way.

Side Four

A+++, another stunner! Big, wide and amazingly three-dimensional, it’s hard to imagine live Crazy Horse sounding much better than this. The guitars jump right out of the speakers, there’s great weight to the low end, and the vocals are tonally Right On The Money (ROTM)!

(more…)

Idlewild South – Listen for Thin, Edgy Vocals

More of the Music of The Allman Brothers

Easily the group’s best sounding studio recording and especially impressive on a copy like this

Drop the needle on Midnight Rider or In Memory Of Elizabeth Read to hear what this copy can do. You get lots of extension here both up top and down low that makes the overall sound far more engaging and musical than what you’d hear on a typical copy.

One of the biggest problems we ran into with this shootout was thin, recessed or edgy vocals. This is a band known for their rockin’ guitar jams, so it shouldn’t be a huge surprise that the vocals are not where they focused their energy when recording.

I wish the vocals here were a bit fuller but at least they have enough presence to put them front and center. (more…)

Sinatra at the Sands – What to Listen For

There is some edge on Sinatra’s voice on every side of every copy; it’s so common it’s got to be on the tape. Those copies with less edge and grit on the vocals which are not overly smooth or dull tend to do very well in our shootouts.

Also, richness is very important. We look for a combination of rich, Tubey Magical sound that still maintains a fair amount of space, clarity, transparency and freedom from smear.

The original label pressings (always in stereo; the monos are really a joke) are richer and thicker as a rule.

The pressings with the orange two-tone labels tend to be thinner and clearer. A high percentage of them are much too modern sounding, bright and gritty, and when they are we throw them right in the trade-in pile.

Finding the copy with “best of both worlds” sound is the trick. Pressings on both labels have won shootouts in the past. With this album we do what we always do. We play the record without looking at the label and simply grade the quality of the sound coming out of the speakers. Any other approach is liable to fall prey to unconscious biases. As we like to say, record shootouts may not be rocket science, but they’re a science of a kind, one with strict protocols developed over the course of many years to insure that the results we arrive at are as accurate as we can possibly make them.

(more…)