More of the music of Igor Stravinsky (1882-1971)
Reviews and Commentaries for the Music of Stravinsky
Sonic Grade: ?
We used to think this was one of the better Speakers Corner Deccas.
Having recently played the London pressing of the same performance, cut by Decca of course, we think we almost certainly wrong about the quality of the sound, but who knows? Maybe Speakers Corner remastered the record properly and fixed its shortcomings?
Hah, just joking. In our experience that has never happened and we think it is very unlikely that it ever will.
Years ago we wrote the following:
Wow! What a performance! What dynamic full bodied sound! To be fair, I pulled out my original London, one of those awful mid-’70s English pressings that are never quiet, and yes, some of the ambience on the original is missing here on the new version, but everything else seems right: dynamics, tonality, the frequency extremes (including some pretty awesome deep bass).
Some of the above could be right, the parts about the tonality and such. Speakers Corner could have added some bass and lower midrange to make the sound less thin, and taken out some of the upper midrange to make the loud passages less blary, but it certainly doesn’t solve the most serious issues we had with the recording, which is the fact that it is opaque and flat, two qualities that are the death of orchestral music on vinyl.
Here are the notes we made for the London.
The two paragraphs you see reproduced below are also full of bad advice we had given out in the past:
1. Can’t be sure we would still feel that way but I’m guessing this is a good record if you can pick one up at a cheap price.
2. If you have a quiet original, great, consider yourself lucky. As few of you have any copy at all, I recommend this one. The alternative is to miss Solti’s energetic performance and the precision of the Chicago Symphony, one of the few orchestras capable of making sense out of this complex and infuriating work. (At least it used to infuriate audiences. Now our modern ears can take a difficult work like this and appreciate the complex rhythms and atonality as the expression of a truly original mind.
This paragraph we would still agree with wholeheartedly:
This is not music to play while you are having dinner. This is music to engage the mind fully. It belongs in any collection. Yours in fact. Unless you have small speakers, in which case you would be wasting your money, as small speakers cannot begin to reproduce the power of this work in the hands of Solti and the CSO [or anybody else for that matter].
More music conducted by Georg Solti