Elgar / Enigma Variations / Monteux / LSO – Reviewed in 2011

More Elgar

More Enigma Variations / Monteux / LSO – 2011


A distinguished member of the Better Records Orchestral Music Hall of Fame.

This famous Shaded Dog, containing two superb performances by Monteux and the LSO, has many of the Golden Age strengths and weaknesses we know well here at Better Records, having played literally hundreds upon hundreds of these vintage pressings over the last twenty years or so. 

Both sides earned sonic grades of at least A+ to A++ (with side one being just a bit better than that but maybe not quite A++). The sound is rich and sweet and full of Living Stereo Magic!  

The wonderful sounding tube compressors that were used back in the day result in quieter passages that are positively swimming in ambience and low-level orchestral detail. Tube compression is, in large part, what we mean when we use the term Tubey Magic. (If you want to know what Zero Tubey Magic sounds like, play some Telarcs or Reference Recordings from the ’70s. Or a modern digital recording on CD.)

But all that sweet and rich Tubey Magic comes at a price when it’s time for the orchestra to get loud. It either can’t, or the louder passages simply distort from compressor overload. Fortunately on this copy the orchestra does not distort, it simply never gets as loud as it would have in a real concert hall, clearly the lesser and more preferable of the two evils.

Side two has lovely texture to the strings. It’s not quite as rich and full as side one, but it does have more extension on the top end, which is somewhat rare for a vintage RCA pressing from 1960.

The cover has some problems so we’ve kept the price down somewhat. Check the Sonic Grade tab to read more.

This recording contains Elgar’s Enigma Variations and Brahms’ Haydn Variations as played by the London Symphony Orchestra under the direction of Pierre Monteux.


Side One

Elgar: Enigma Variations, Op. 36 ( Part I)

Side Two

Elgar: Enigma Variations, Op. 36 (Concluded) 
Brahms: Variations on a Theme of Haydn, Op. 56 A

See more recordings engineered by Kenneth Wilkinson
See more recordings made in Kingsway Hall