Skeptical Thinking Is Critical to Achieving Better Sound
There are some things that must certainly be impossible.
Nobody who thinks they can levitate should be taken at his word. There would need to be very strong evidence for such a thing before we could agree that the laws of gravity need a rewrite.
But what about the laws of audio?
First of all, with due consideration to the null hypothesis, are there any such things, and, if there are, how good is the evidence to back them up?
After 50 years in audio I am not aware of any audio laws having any basis in fact. But that doesn’t mean that there aren’t important aspects of audio and records of which we are ignorant.
Keeping in mind that each of us is searching for truth in audio in his or her own way, there are some general questions we all need to consider.
- Are there aspects of audio reproduction that you may not be aware of?
- Are there stereos that reproduce music at a much higher level than any of those you have heard, regardless of price?
- Are there ways to make your stereo sound better than those you know of?
- Are there record pressings that sound better than the ones you’ve heard?
To all these questions you should be open to answers that are new to you. This is a core belief here at Better Records: We don’t pretend to know it all (and we hope that you don’t either).
To gain a better understanding of the realities of the vinyl pressing, let’s consider the following evidence.
Looking at the Data
There has never been a case in which a person contacted me and told me that they played a pile of copies of a particular album and that, contrary to one of our bedrock beliefs, they all sounded the same.
It’s never happened. The closest anyone has ever come is that Michael Fremer years ago said that he played three copies of the original pressing of Aja and all three sounded very similar and all three sounded very good.
That might be true. The originals of that record, with either the AB or AA prefix catalog number, tend to be consistently good sounding, if our experience with scores of them can be taken into account.
On the system Mr. Fremer was using all those years ago, there might not have been enough of a difference to be sure that there was any difference at all. (More grist for the mill of the null hypothesis.)
As I said at the time, those three records, properly cleaned and played back on good equipment, as good as the equipment we own at any rate, would have very little chance of sounding the same. They would most likely all sound very good, but there would be obvious differences in the sound, and unquestionably differences in the sonic grades given to each side. It’s just the way records work. They all sound different, and some are clearly better than others, no matter how similar they look.
We know all that because we do this for a living. We do double blinded tests so that only the grooves of the records we play are allowed to tell us what they sound like — not the labels, not the stampers, not the mastering credits on the jacket, none of that stuff.
We don’t assume and we don’t guess. We don’t let them just blend together. We listen for the differences so that we can sort them all out and rank them highest to lowest.
But back to the idea of a big pile of records sounding the same.
It has never happened in one of our shootouts, and no customers have ever said it happened to them either. Those who ridicule the idea of all records sounding different are doing so without empirical evidence to support their claim. (This is standard operating procedure in audiophile circles. Opinions are offered liberally, but non-anecdotal evidence to support them is rare.)
You may not be able to levitate, but you are definitely able to hear the differences between ten copies of an album if you clean them and play them back under controlled conditions.
Predictably, the best sounding copy and the worst sounding copy of those ten are sure to sound dramatically different from each other. Naturally some of the ten will sound quite similar, but few of the ten will sound similar enough so that you can’t tell them apart playing head to head. With careful listening and high quality playback each of them will reveal to you their individual strengths and weaknesses.
Of course you have to be using high quality equipment that has been properly tweaked and tuned, is being fed by good electricity, has been set up in a good room, and all the other things that must be optimized in order to reproduce music with high fidelity in the home.
Such systems are hard to come by. One thing you can be sure of is that the folks who believe in the idea that two identical looking records must sound the same not only don’t have one, they have probably never even heard one.
Further Reading
- What I couldn’t hear on my 90s tube system
- It may be hard to believe, but we actually enjoy testing records
- Here are some of the reasons you must do your own shootouts if you want better sound

